techdirt.com
from the not-understanding-the-technology dept
Okay, this is just getting ridiculous. A few weeks back, we noted that Senators Amy Klobuchar, John Cornyn and Christopher Coons had proposed a new bill that was designed to make "streaming" infringing material a felony. At the time, the actual text of the bill wasn't available, but we assumed, naturally, that it would just extend "public performance" rights to section 506a of the Copyright Act.
Supporters of this bill claim that all it's really doing is harmonizing US copyright law's civil and criminal sections. After all, the rights afforded under copyright law in civil cases cover a list of rights: reproduce, distribute, prepare derivative works or perform the work. The rules for criminal infringement only cover reproducing and distributing -- but not performing. So, supporters claim, all this does is "harmonize" copyright law and bring the criminal side into line with the civil side by adding "performance rights" to the list of things.
If only it were that simple. But, of course, it's not. First of all, despite claims to the contrary, there's a damn good reason why Congress did not include performance rights as a criminal/felony issue: because who would have thought that it would be a criminal act to perform a work without permission? It could be infringing, but that can be covered by a fine. When we suddenly criminalize a performance, that raises all sorts of questionable issues.
Furthermore, as we suspected, in the full text of the bill, "performance" is not clearly defined. This is the really troubling part. Everyone keeps insisting that this is targeted towards "streaming" websites, but is streaming a "performance"? If so, how does embedding play into this? Is the site that hosts the content guilty of performing? What about the site that merely linked to and/or embedded the video (linking and embedding are technically effectively the same thing). Without clear definitions, we run into problems pretty quickly.
And it gets worse. Because rather than just (pointlessly) adding "performance" to the list, the bill tries to also define what constitutes a potential felony crime in these circumstances:
the offense consists of 10 or more public performances by electronic means, during any 180-day period, of 1 or more copyrighted works
So yeah. If you embed a YouTube video that turns out to be infringing, and more than 10 people view it because of your link... you could be facing five years in jail. This is, of course, ridiculous, and suggests (yet again) politicians who are regulating a technology they simply do not understand. Should it really be a criminal act to embed a YouTube video, even if you don't know it was infringing...? This could create a massive chilling effect to the very useful service YouTube provides in letting people embed videos.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
About Me
Blog Archive
-
▼
2011
(1028)
-
▼
June
(93)
- Prices skyrocket as fuel and power crisis sores ac...
- Police Taser, Beat, Pepper Spray Mentally Handicap...
- Shepherding chihuahua proves size doesn’t matter
- Joyce Riley: They Are Flooding Us On Purpose! Unde...
- Feds Buying Up Farmland They Flooded; Soros In On It
- Foreigners must register fingerprints, facial scans
- FEMA, FCC Announce Nationwide Test Of The Emergenc...
- WKUK Season 5 - Little Hitler
- Poll: Texans prefer Obama over Perry
- Mike Beck and the Bohemian Saints: George Orwells ...
- 3 students die after being hypnotized by principal
- U.S. cost of war at least $3.7 trillion and counting
- Richard Hoagland NASA Preparedness Speech on Coast...
- U.S. Drug Policy Fails Sick Patients and Taxpayers
- Texas Miracle Seen as a Not-Miracle
- Suzanne Vega - Luka
- INCOMING! Asteroid to Narrowly Miss Earth on Monday
- The Shift is About to Hit the Fan!
- Brady Bunch mom got crabs in affair with NY mayor
- Gay Marriage Equality Passes in New York State
- American in Tripoli: First Hand Account
- Pakistan army rejects report on bin Laden's cell-p...
- The Purposeful Flooding of America's Heartland
- The Path of the Moon and Sun
- Mysterious Deaths of 9/11 Witnesses (MUST SEE)
- 9/11 Truth, "Conspiracy Theories," And The Crisis ...
- RECON ALERT: Suspicious Military Convoy Seen Near ...
- Something strange is going on at Lake Delton, WI -...
- Florida sold citizens’ driver’s license informatio...
- THE LOW-CUT SHIRT - An Interactive Adventure!
- Ron Paul says legalize marijuana CNBC 6-22-2011
- Fear of Terrorism Makes People Stupid
- New bill ending federal ban on marijuana to be int...
- Name That Country
- Senators Want To Put People In Jail For Embedding ...
- Military Transporting Explosives to Joplin Mo?
- Backward at the F.B.I.
- Breaking The Taboo 2011 | Official Trailer (Englis...
- Howlin' for You - Black Keys
- Ron Paul on Today: I’m not a fringe candidate
- Etta James - Sunday Kind Of Love
- True Blood Opening Credits
- Ultimate Dog Tease
- Blue Tip (official) | The Cars
- Call Off the Global Drug War
- 311 - Sunset In July
- US Naval and Troop Movements Toward North Africa, ...
- The Black Keys - Howlin' For You (Official Video)
- Globalists Want Permanent Occupation of Iraq
- Comet Elenin - Planet X - Nibiru and the Mayan Wo...
- Gaddafi proposes elections as NATO strikes continue
- Moon Dreams
- U.S. Invasion of Libya Set for October
- Magic mushroom’s positive effects lasting over a y...
- Dream Terror Attack for Obama - Qaddafi/9-11 Truth...
- Cannabinoid Administration Halts Disease Progressi...
- Texas Gov. Rick Perry describes himself as ‘a prop...
- Flaunt your bod - charge your pod
- U.S. Congress votes against Libya funding
- Ordinance Would Force Property Owners to Surrender...
- Bad News from NASA: Proof That Comet Elenin Is Aff...
- U.S. Government Secretly Flooded Mexico With Weapons
- Chinese scientists genetically modify dairy cows t...
- First therapeutic study of LSD in 35 years finishe...
- Hillary Clinton interested in becoming head of Wor...
- On the prowl for horror
- Texas agency: Authorities take gunfire on border
- China calls for prompt ceasefire in Libya
- FDA finally admits chicken meat contains cancer-ca...
- 2011
- Gun Control - It Doesn't Work
- Caffeine linked to hallucinations in study - but h...
- Why did Obama release electronic birth certificate?
- Solar Flare Sparks Biggest Eruption Ever Seen on Sun
- Hot Particles Reach West Coast of U.S.
- Do You Like Your Constitutional Rights?
- Connecticut Legislature Decriminalizes Marijuana
- FDA sends US marshals to seize elderberry juice co...
- Katie Couric signs deal for ABC talk show
- Webster Tarpley & Elite's Plan for Global Extermin...
- Forensic evidence emerges that European e.coli sup...
- The War in Iraq is Over - Right?
- Elizabeth Taylor as You've Never Seen Her Before: ...
- Choose a Reality
- Hey Marcel - Watch This
- TSA On The Ropes; Budget Slashed, Texas Grope Ban ...
- Pentagon: Hack attacks can be act of war
- The Cannibal Cafe
- America's Creeping Police State
- Former world leaders say decriminalizing marijuana...
- House Republicans Kill Kucinich’s Libya Withdrawal...
- Sooner Tea Party offices ransacked, records stolen
- NATO saving face, not civilians in Libya
-
▼
June
(93)
1 comment:
Ted - I never thought about that angle, could be.
That guy thought he was a hotdog, turned out to be just a Wiener.
Post a Comment